What FIPS 186-5 signature mistakes should teams avoid?
Do not reuse signature keys. FIPS 186-5 says digital signature key pairs must not be used for other purposes such as key establishment, and it repeats that RSA and ECDSA signature keys are signature-only. A key inventory should therefore show a signature-only purpose rather than a shared public-key bucket.
Successful signature verification is not the whole validation decision. For ECDSA and EdDSA, verifiers also need domain-parameter assurance; verifiers need public-key validity, claimed-signatory identity, and possession assurance before accepting a signature as valid. Conformance to FIPS 186-5 also does not guarantee system security; the standard leaves implementation security and overall system assurance to the responsible implementer or authority.
- Do not use a signature key pair for key establishment, encryption, or other non-signature purposes.
- Do not claim DSA signature generation as approved under FIPS 186-5; limit DSA to the legacy verification context supported by the standard.
- Do not reuse a CAVP certificate across a different implementation, version, operating environment, parameter set, or module boundary without confirming the scope.
Supports key-purpose separation, assurance checks before accepting signatures as valid, and the limits of conformance claims.
Clarifies that approved-service indicators may depend on the signature algorithm, hash algorithm, and key size used by the service.